Migration for employment is an unequal process. Within this reality, migrating communities continue to find social space that allows them to have one foot in the destination country even while keeping the other in their homeland. ... MORE ...
Tuesday, 30 September 2014
Clearance mela
With development high on its agenda, the BJP Government is pushing through environmental clearances in order to remove all perceived bottlenecks that hinder growth. ... MORE ...
Organic farming and corporates
The entry of big business the organic farming movement's raison d'etre - to counter the corporatisation of agricultural practices. ... MORE ...
Tuesday, 17 June 2014
What makes SEZs controversial?
It is a good idea to publish books around the time of national elections. They catch readers’ attention. Especially so during the recent fiercely fought national elections when many topical titles appeared on the bookshelves in the past months. ...MORE ...
Monday, 16 June 2014
Air of uncertainty
Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar will not have to worry about pressures from alliance
partners. But one does not know how much space he is willing to carve out for himself and how much space the government is likely to give him. ... MORE ...
Wednesday, 7 May 2014
Are the national elections bipolar?
Turn on any television channel and you
will think that India is going through bipolar national elections. It is like a
boxing match, being fought in proxy. In one corner is one man, Narendra
Modi, ably represented by whoever his spokesperson is in the studio that
evening. In the other corner is the Gandhi family, again represented by an
articulate spokesperson.
Somewhere the richness and colour of the
regional parties that became the integral part of Indian polity since 1996
seems to be missing in the predominant media representation of these elections.
Conspicuous by their near-absence in the media coverage in this year’s
elections are dramatis personae such
as Lalu Prasad Yadav, Mayawati, Nitish Kumar, Navin Patnaik, M. Karunanidhi,
etc. Mamata Banerjee, Chandrababu Naidu and Omar Abdullah make occasional
appearance.
Cut back to the period between 1995 and 1998, when the country was preparing for the 1996 general elections and also when the United Front Government faced many trust motions in Parliament. The television screens were full of leaders from regional political parties.
|
Plantations such as this cardamom estate in Idukki district have been in the eye of a political storm in the recent months [Pic: Varun Warrier] |
A trend towards bipolarity has its
implications for environmental decisions in an ecosystem-diverse country like
India. Take for instance the case of the mid-altitude plateaus of Kerala,
represented by Idukki and Wayanad districts, which have been in the news during
the run-up to these elections. At an average altitude between 800 and 1000
metres, these plateaus were malaria-prone regions. As with the Gudalur plateau in
Tamil Nadu contiguous to Wayanad, these plateaus were only sparsely populated
till the 1940s. The influx of settlers came when there was effective medical
cure for malaria (1).
Those who initially went to settle in
these plateaus were from communities that were landless and had the daring to
go to dangerous terrains. While the landed gentry stayed back in the plains,
and boasted about temple festivals and caparisoned elephants, the landless
settlers braved the wild elephant herds and cultivated every inch of land they
could lay their hands on. The women tended the farms, protected the children
from wild animals while the men trekked for days to the nearest market town to
sell what the family produced.
When this settler community gets slapped
with orders emerging from the Kasturirangan Committee limiting their
activities, it protests (2). While one can argue on the conservation versus livelihoods debate,
the fact remains that if a representative has to take these issues effectively
to the Parliament it has to be someone who is from the region and knows its
history and ecology. He or she needs a political agenda that is tailor-made to
represent the interests of the region, and not one that has been averaged out
for the entire country. And this is where regional parties score over omnibus
national parties.
The 1996 general elections and the years
of the United Front Government was the period when regionalism and federalism
bloomed in the country. By this time the results from two socio-economic processes
initiated between 1989 and 1991 were maturing. As part of the economic
liberalisation there was a focus on the middle class as a consumer base for the
goods and services. This created a new kind of economic aspiration for a wider
group of people. This bolstered the aspirations for development and growth from
caste and region-based consolidations that were born after the implementation
of the Mandal Committee report in 1989 (3).
Happening in parallel with this was a
coming together of local environmental movements to demand greater
accountability from the electoral candidates in select constituencies. A group
of organisations, led by Narmada Bachao Andolan, established the National Alliance
of People’s Movement (NAPM), with an aim of bringing people’s issues into the
agenda of the 1996 elections (4). Similarly, another group of environmental organisations formed a
network called the Jan Vikas Andolan to publicly question candidates on their
environmental concerns (5).
However, it is not the case that regional
parties are more environment friendly than the national ones. In fact, the
trend in the mid 1990s was that each of the regional parties was pushing for
development projects in their regions, oftentimes unmindful of incorporating
environmental safeguards.
The difference is that the feedback loops
between the people and the policymakers are shorter with regional parties. So
when people ask for development or conservation that is location or
ecosystem-specific they can communicate and get action for their needs quickly
and effectively. The accountability for the policy maker becomes that much
sharper. For instance, Chandrababu Naidu of the Telugu Desam party, who
focussed on the urban areas at the cost of the larger rural population, has had
to sit out for a decade.
At a local level, the perceived dichotomy
between development and conservation also disappears. For the
demarcation of the ecologically sensitive area (ESA) the Western Ghats Ecology
Expert Panel (Madhav Gadgil Committee) had recommended consultations through
the local bodies under the Panchayats and Biodiversity Acts (6). The High Level Working Group on Western Ghats (Kasturirangan
Committee), which was tasked to work out the modalities for implementing the
earlier committee’s recommendations, overlooked this and went through marking
the ESAs using satellite imagery (7). And this is causing the controversy in the hill districts.
So much so that the Ministry of
Environment and Forests (MoEF) had to make amendments to its 13 October 2013
notification, accepting the recommendations of the Kasturirangan Committee that
declared 37% area of the Western Ghats as an ESA where development activities
are restricted.
Through an office memorandum dated 20
December 2013, MoEF stated that the boundary of the ESA and the regulatory
regime would be finalised after obtaining the views of the stakeholders and
state governments. MoEF assured that the recommendations will not cause
restrictions to any normal activities related to plantations and agriculture; and
that the restrictions listed in the notification will apply only to new and
expansion projects, and not to the existing ones.
The Kasturirangan Committee reportedly used
higher resolution satellite imagery than the Gadgil Committee while demarcating
the ESA. However, technical minutiae cannot replace a broad-based democratic
process that would have been more acceptable to the people on the ground.
So when the media represents these
elections as bipolar, what is being lost is the space that accommodates the
various nuances of development and environment discussions in the country.
It could be possible that the media is
reading the situation wrong or over-presenting bipolarity. In the theatre of
talk shows and televised shouting matches, bipolarity adds drama.
There is reality and there is the media’s
perception of the reality. The country today has access only to the media’s
perception of reality. Will the real picture be as bipolar as what is being
made out will be clear on May 16.
_______________________
1. Adams
T. Gudalur: A community at the crossroads. In: Hockings P, editor. Blue
Mountains: The ethnography and biogeography of a South Indian region: Oxford
University Press; 1989.
2. Rajagopal
K. Ghats row and its aftermath. The Hindu. 20 March 2014.
3. Ramakrishnan
V, Singh SR. Vital pieces of a jigsaw. Frontline. 16 April 2014.
4. Warrier
SG. The centre will hold. The Hindu Business Line. 26 February 1996.
5. Warrier
SG. Eco issues may feature in select LS campaigns. The Hindu Business
Line. 27 March 1996.
6. Report
of the Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel. Ministry of Environment and Forests,
Government of India; 2011.
7. Report
of the High Level Working Group on Western Ghats. Ministry of Environment and
Forests, Government of India; 2013.
Monday, 21 April 2014
Young voters and the green argument
In 1959, the Times of India had a special
publication to celebrate Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru’s 70th birth year. The
Indo-China war had not happened and Nehru’s popularity had not taken the
nosedive. He had been in power for 12 years, long enough to assess his
governance.
The thick volume – A study of Nehru (1) – was edited by Rafiq Zakaria, then a columnist with Times of India,
and later a Member of Parliament and minister in the Maharastra Government.
Zakaria had collected and edited essays on Nehru from leaders across political
and civil life in India and across the world. Josip Broz Tito, Gamal Abdel
Nasser, Kwame Nkrumah, Clement Atlee, Louis Mountbatten, S. Radhakrishnan,
E.M.S Namboodiripad, S.A. Dange and R.K. Laxman were among those who
contributed to the volume. Some essays praised Nehru, a few others ran him down
and there were some that kept the balance.
![]() |
|
Accumulating
urban waste is high on the list of
environment problems for the young voter. |
The essays in the volume gave Nehru depth
and life. Whether supporting or pillorying him, they argued cogently, with clarity
of thought and public purpose rarely seen in the present times.
These leaders were unencumbered by the
present-day distractions – popping e-mails, SMS messages, Tweets and Facebook
posts. No shouting television anchors, talk shows, opinion polls and exit
polls.
We are a country of argumentative people
and right now we are going through a period when our arguments have reached
their crescendo. More than half the country’s voters have exercised their
franchise, but those remaining to vote can make a serious impact. There is an
aggression and desperation simultaneously as parties go for the kill.
Elections 2014 has a strong component to
the arguments, discussions and debates from young voters. Of the total of 814.5
million about 100 million (2) are casting their votes for the first time. And among these
first-timers, 23.6 million have just turned 18 years of age. The voters
represent the demographic profile of the population, and according to the 2011
census 28.9% of the population is between 18 and 35 years of age (3), emphasising the strong involvement of young voters this year.
What is the environmental consciousness
of these young voters and how is it likely to affect their voting? Even the
oldest in the 18 to 35 age group would have just been born around the end of
the 1970s when the landmark controversy of modern Indian environmental history
– over the construction of a dam for a hydro-electric project flooding the
Silent Valley rainforest in Kerala – was raging.
They would have been too young to register
the impact of the Bhopal gas leak in 1984, or the sit-in by the anti-Narmada
Dam movement at Ferkuva in 1990-91. Essentially the environment consciousness
of this group would have become active after the economic liberalisation was
launched in the country in 1991.
Environmental understanding for this
generation that has had its awakening in the post-liberalised India is
different from that of the earlier generations. In the first half of the 1990s there
was a transition in the manner in which people thought about the environment
and how they acted to protect it.
Two decades ago, when the activists of
the Narmada Bachao Andolan, led by Medha Patkar, marched to Ferkuva in the
Madhya Pradesh-Gujarat border, or when they sat along the banks of the Narmada
river braving the rising waters of the river repeating “doobenge par hatenge nahin” (we may drown but will not move), they
were pitting the moral strength of individuals against the might of the State.
The
same was true when Sundarlal Bahuguna sat in protest on the banks of the
Bhagirathi river in Tehri Garhwal in the present-day Uttarakhand.
The equation, as perceived then, was that
industrial capital and the State were two different entities, but was coalescing
to take away people’s access to their natural resources. The citizen had to
protest this with the State.
After the impact of the economic
liberalisation started in the mid-1990s, the boundaries between capital and the
State blurred and it was difficult to pit the citizen’s moral strength against
an amorphous entity. The young lived and drew sustenance from the liberalised
economy, thus their lives were same (or they aspired for it to be same) as that
of their class enemies. Thus, the broad-brush protests of the anti-Narmada and anti-Tehri
dam movements became ineffective in dealing with environmental problems.
It was necessary to have specific,
targeted action. Thus by the second half of 1990s, like their counterparts in
the West, environment activists in India took to fighting legal cases,
campaigning through the media, lobbying with Parliamentarians and carrying out
e-mail campaigns. These were project-based environmental confrontations.
However, the romance of the protest
remained. The romance was revived when Anna Hazare sat on protest at Ramlila
Maidan in New Delhi in August 2011. The urban middle class youngster enjoyed
the novelty of protesting, but had to get back with his/her life after a few
days. And there were messages on Facebook: “Anna-ji
maan jayiye!” (please do agree, Anna). Fashionable protest is different
from protest to protect livelihoods.
The Hazare movement evolved into the Aam
Aadmi Party (AAP) and the novelty of the concept attracted the youth. Here was
an opportunity to fight the “corrupt politicians.” But when the dream party
resigned from the Delhi Government, some of its sheen was lost. There are
“murmurings” though, as social scientist Shiv Visvanathan points out (4), but these are from the livelihood protestors in regions such as
the Kolar gold mines in Karnataka.
Some of the sheen that the AAP lost in
the perception of the young voter has accrued to the BJP account. Development,
nationalism, growth, change, “Vikas
Purush”, etc., are the keywords that the BJP is using to tap into it.
In the glossary of environmental-civic
problems of these young voters there would be mention of urban garbage, sewage
problems, air pollution, pot-holed roads and inadequate public transport.
Unsafe municipal water supply may not appear, since water reaches homes in
plastic containers. Neither will there be a mention of the risk of climate
change for farmers.
These keywords are the ones playing out
on Twitter, Facebook and the television talk shows. The messages, however, are
disjointed and sporadic.
Unlike in the time of Nehru, there are
far too many messages in far too many media types communicated by far too many
people. Teasing out a narrative from all this has so far been near impossible
in this year’s elections.
__________________
1. A
study of Nehru. 1960 ed: Times of India; 1959.
2. Sharma
R. Electorate 2014. Frontline. 18
April 2014.
3. Mishra
AR, Anuja, Tandon S, Verma G. Census profiles the young Indian voter, spender.
Live Mint. 7 September 2013.
4. Visvanathan
S. The future and the AAP. The Hindu.
16 April 2014.
Related blogs:
Related blogs:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
